Funeral Questions
Grief & LossSolved

My Mother-in-Law Said 'At Least It Was Early' After My Miscarriage

3 min read2 replies
Original Question

Asked by muted_marigold7 ·

I miscarried two weeks ago at eight weeks. My husband was back at work within two days, which I understand practically, but he also just seems... back to normal, and I'm not sure how to bring that up without it turning into a fight about who's a bad parent-in-waiting or whatever.

What's actually knocked me sideways is my mother-in-law. She found out and said "well, at least it was early, these things happen for a reason" and then changed the subject to something about the garden. I don't think she meant to be cruel. I just haven't been able to stop thinking about it since. Am I overreacting because it was only eight weeks? Everyone keeps implying, without quite saying it, that this should be a smaller thing than it feels like.

From the knowledge baseHow Do You Cope With Grief After a Miscarriage or Pregnancy Loss?

2 Replies

mossy_teacup
Accepted Answer

You're not overreacting, and eight weeks doesn't put a ceiling on how much this is allowed to hurt. Grief here tracks the future you'd already started imagining, not the number on a calendar. That's true whether a loss happens at six weeks or six months.

On your husband: it's very common for partners to grieve on a different timeline, and it doesn't reliably mean he's less affected. He didn't carry the pregnancy, so the loss can feel less physically present to him even when it's just as real emotionally. Some people process by going quiet or throwing themselves back into routine rather than talking. Worth naming plainly rather than guessing: "I'm not trying to catch you out, I just need to know you're grieving this too, even if it looks different to how I am" tends to open the door better than watching and drawing conclusions from a distance. A session or two with a GP-referred counsellor, together, can also help if talking about it directly feels hard to start.

On your mother-in-law: "at least it was early" is one of the most common things people say precisely because they don't know what else to say, not because they've decided your loss doesn't count. That doesn't make it land any less badly, but it's worth separating the awkwardness from actual malice before deciding how much energy to spend on it. If it's still sitting with you, a short, calm correction later, something like "it still hurt a lot, even though it was early," tends to do more than confronting her over the comment itself.

This piece on coping with grief after a miscarriage or pregnancy loss goes through both of these (differing partner grief and other people's dismissive comments) in more detail, plus Pink Elephants and SANDS, who specialise in exactly this kind of loss if you'd rather talk to someone who isn't family.

brackish_lark

I had almost this exact comment said to me, word for word close enough that it startled me reading your post. What helped me eventually wasn't getting an apology or even a better comment from anyone. It was finding one or two people (a friend, and later a Pink Elephants peer group) who didn't need the loss explained or justified to them at all. You don't have to get your mother-in-law to understand it properly for your grief to be valid. Sometimes it's more peaceful to let that one relationship be a bit clumsy about it and put your energy into the people who already get it.

Related Discussions